When it’s mandatory
A handful of states unequivocally mandate the involvement of a licensed attorney in a real estate transaction. These states take a dim view of non-attorney staff members preparing and conducting real estate settlements, calling such acts an “unauthorized practice of law.” This phrase actually derives from the rules of professional conduct (i.e., ethics) that govern attorney practice, and can result in sanctions against an attorney-supervisor for allowing this unauthorized practice with minimal oversight. Currently, Delaware, Georgia, New York, North Carolina, and South Carolina require attorney involvement, oversight, and direction in all aspects of a real estate transfer, from title review to signing documents. In Alabama, a non-attorney can perform a title search and issue title insurance, as long as a licensed attorney drafts all legal documents (e.g., deeds, mortgages and promissory notes). In all these states, the buyer has the unequivocal right to choose his or her legal representation; realtors, brokers, and lenders are not generally permitted to force a buyer to work with a certain attorney.When it’s complex
For buyers in other states, working with a real estate attorney may still be advisable if the situation involves a complex or unique issue, such as:- Oil and gas rights
- Riparian rights (i.e., access to water)
- Beachfront property
- Any property subject to an easement
- Adverse possession claim
- Historical property
- Preserved property (i.e., farm preservation)
- Zoning and/or land use disputes